Minor bug glitch re: Earned Run

[RandySteinman]

Had a weird box score glitch today. 1952 Pirates beat the '39 Browns 3-2. (Note: no errors for Pittsburgh)…

–

Here’s how St. Louis scored its first run, in the top of the fifth…

It is the top of the 5th

St. Louis STLA rolls a 4 and 5
It’s a 14 on Don HEFFNER’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll
Using Fielding 3
Result: Base on balls; batter takes 1st (ZZ pitcher: 2 balls)
Don HEFFNER walks, takes first.

St. Louis STLA rolls a 5 and 2
It’s a 27 on Joe GALLAGHER’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll
Using Fielding 3
Result: Out at 1st; runner to 2nd; A-3B PO-1B (X-SO; PO-C)
Joe GALLAGHER grounds out, Sonny SENERCHIA to Tony BARTIROME.

St. Louis STLA rolls a 2 and 2
It’s a 0 on George McQUINN’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll

St. Louis STLA rolls a 2 and 1
It’s a 6 on George McQUINN’s card.
Result: DOUBLE to left center; runner scores
George McQUINN DOUBLES to left center, Don HEFFNER scores.
1 run scores.

–

And here’s how the Browns’ second run was scored in the top of the 7th…

It is the top of the 7th

St. Louis STLA rolls a 1 and 2
It’s a 25 on Don HEFFNER’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll
Using Fielding 3
Result: Out at 1st; A-2B PO-1B (X-SO; PO-C)
Don HEFFNER grounds out, Johnny MERSON to Tony BARTIROME.

St. Louis STLA rolls a 2 and 1
It’s a 30 on Joe GALLAGHER’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll
Using Fielding 3
Result: Fly out; PO-LF (K-SO;PO-C)
Joe GALLAGHER flies out to Pete CASTIGLIONE.

St. Louis STLA rolls a 3 and 3
It’s a 0 on George McQUINN’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll

St. Louis STLA rolls a 2 and 5
It’s a 2 on George McQUINN’s card.
Result: TRIPLE to left center
George McQUINN TRIPLES to left center.

St. Louis STLA rolls a 1 and 5
It’s an 8 on Harlond CLIFT’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll
Result: SINGLE over 2nd; runner scores
Harlond CLIFT SINGLES over second, George McQUINN scores.
1 run scores.

–

Two fairly straightforward runs for the Browns. No errors or passed balls were involved. Yet, in the final box score, Pirates’ pitcher Woody Main (who went the distance) is charged with only ONE earned run…

Not a biggie, that’s for sure. But there’s a minor bug in there somewhere. Strange thing is… I’m not even sure which of the two runs was credited as being unearned…

[anluc7]

Seems like a home town Official scorer move. lol

[RandySteinman]

Another one today. Roger Craig (D) gave up four runs in the bottom of the third, all of which were earned. Yet the final box score shows that the runs went into the books as unearned…

It is the bottom of the 3rd

Pittsburgh PIT rolls a 3 and 3
It’s a 7 on Murry DICKSON’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll
Result: SINGLE to right
Murry DICKSON SINGLES to right.

Pittsburgh PIT rolls a 1 and 1
It’s a 0 on Pete CASTIGLIONE’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll

Pittsburgh PIT rolls a 3 and 2
It’s a 7 on Pete CASTIGLIONE’s card.
Result: SINGLE to right; runner to 3rd
Pete CASTIGLIONE SINGLES to right, Murry DICKSON to 3rd.

Pittsburgh PIT rolls a 2 and 3
It’s a 29 on Dick GROAT’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll
Using Fielding 3
Result: Out at 1st; runner to 2nd; other holds A-P PO-1B (K-SO; PO-C)
Roger CRAIG fields Dick GROAT’s come backer, looks Murry DICKSON back to third and throws Dick GROAT out at first. Runners at second and third.

Pittsburgh PIT rolls a 4 and 5
It’s a 14 on Gus BELL’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll
Using Fielding 3
Result: Base on balls; filling the bases
BASES LOADED. Roger CRAIG walks Gus BELL to load them up.

Pittsburgh PIT rolls a 4 and 2
It’s a 14 on Ralph KINER’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll
Using Fielding 3
Result: Base on balls; filling the bases(Z or ZZ pitcher: 2 balls)

Pittsburgh PIT takes the lead!
Ralph KINER walks in a run. Bases are still loaded. Give Ralph KINER a RBI. Clarence COLEMAN is looking at the pitcher but complaining to the ump.
1 run scores.

Pittsburgh PIT rolls a 3 and 3
It’s a 0 on Joe GARAGIOLA’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll

Pittsburgh PIT rolls a 4 and 2
It’s a 2 on Joe GARAGIOLA’s card.
Result: TRIPLE to extreme left field
Joe GARAGIOLA triples to extreme left field. All three runners score.
3 runs score.

Pittsburgh PIT rolls a 5 and 4
It’s a 32 on Catfish METKOVICH’s card.
User has manually entered dice roll
Using Fielding 3
Result: Fly out; runner scores; PO-RF (S out at home; DP; A-RF PO-C)
Sub-Result: runner3-speed-slow
Catfish METKOVICH flies out into double play, Richie ASHBURN to Clarence COLEMAN; Joe GARAGIOLA out at home.

It is the top of the 4th

[RandySteinman]

Still happening. Cardinals (Bats 3 Pre) scored only one run off the Reds’ Paul Derringer in a 6-1 loss.

It occurred in the bottom of the sixth:
FLYOUT to RF
FOUL BALL
FLYOUT to CF
DOUBLE
TRIPLE
FLYOUT to SS

Definitely an earned run. Yet the box score (and Collections) claims it is unearned.

[striker2550]

Still happening…