1957 Chicago White Sox Replay.
-
@apba-go-jeremy Thanks for following along. It will be interesting to see if the Sox can indeed hold off the Yankees down the stretch.
-
The Sox open the home-stand by taking 2 of 3 from the Senators.
In game 1, Jim Wilson got roughed up early, giving up 4 runs in 3 2/3 innings, but the White Sox rallied for a 7-5 win, making a winner out of Jack Harshman in relief. Dick Donovan worked the final 2 innings for a save. Sherm Lollar blasted a 3-run homer in the game, his 7th of the year.
Game 2 was a complete game, 3-hit shutout by Bob Keegan. Luis Aparicio went 4 for 5 with 2 runs scored for the Sox as they prevailed 5-0.
The Senators avoided the sweep, winning 6-2 behind a complete game effort from Russ Kemmerer. The Sox scored 2 runs in the bottom of the 9th to avoid being shutout. Roy Sievers went 4 for 5 with a homer and 3 RBI for Washington.
The White Sox are now 6 games ahead of their pace:
and they lead the Yankees by 5 games:
Next up for Chicago is 2 games against the Red Sox and then 2 against the Orioles.
-
The White Sox take both games from the Red Sox.
Game 1: Chicago 4 Boston 2. Billy Pierce (12-13) gives up 2 runs over 7 innings. Gerry Staley works the final 2 innings for his 13th save of the season. Minnie Minoso goes 3 for 4 with a double. Jim Piersall and Frank Malzone each collect a pair of hits in the loss.
Game 2: Chicago 4 Boston 3 11 Innings. Earl Torgeson hits a 3-run homer and Luis Aparicio drives in the winning run with a sac fly in the bottom of the 11th. Gerry Staley worked the 11th inning to get the win (7-2). Dick Donovan gave up 3 runs in 10 innings of work. Billy Klaus went 2 for 4 with a homer and a double in a losing effort.
The White Sox remain 6 games ahead of their 1957 pace, and the now lead the Yankees by 5 1/2 games. The Orioles come to town next for a pair of games.
-
Sunday, August 25th. The White Sox dominate the Orioles and sweep a doubleheader winning 8 to 1 and 9 to 0.
In game one, Bob Keegan (8-2, 2.87) went the distance, giving up just one unearned run. Sherm Lollar went 3 for 4 with a double and 2 RBI for the Sox. Bob Nieman drove in the lone Orioles run.
In game two, Jack Harshman (12-6, 3.22) went the distance, scattering 5 hits. Larry Doby went 2 for 3 with 3 RBI to lead the Sox. Joe Durham went 2 for 4 in the loss for Baltimore.
The Yankees now come to town for 3 games, trailing the Sox by 7 full games.
-
The White Sox seize control of the Pennant race with a 3-game sweep of the Yankees. The Sox have now won 7 consecutive games, and 11 out of their last 12.
In the first game against the Yankees, Jim Wilson (13-6) went 7 innings, giving up 1 run on 4 hits. Gerry Staley worked the final 2 innings for his 13th save, closing out the 4-1 victory. The Yankees lone run came on a Hank Bauer homer. Luis Aparico set the table for the Sox, going 2 for 4 with a walk and 2 runs scored. Art Ditmar took the loss for the Yankees.
In game 2, Billy Pierce (13-13) and Gerry Staley (14 Saves) combined on a 2-hit shutout of the Yankees. Luis Aparicio collected 2 more hits for the Sox. Final score: 2-0.
In the final game of the series, Dick Donovan (17-4) went the distance, scattering 8 hits, and giving up 1 run. Tom Sturdivant started and took the loss for New York, giving up 4 runs in 5 1/3 innings. Minnie Minoso went 2 for 3 with 3 RBI for the Sox. Moose Skowron went 2 for 4 and scored the lone run for the Yankees.
The White Sox are now 9 games ahead of their actual pace from 1957:
Chicago leads the league by 9 1/2 games over the Yankees:
The Yankees and Sox will only meet one more time this season, a 2-game set in New York on September 13th and 14th. If the Yankees are going to catch the Sox, they are going to need help from the rest of the teams in the league.
Next up for the Sox is a 6-game road trip that starts with 3 games in Kansas City.
-
The White Sox continue to roll along through September 3rd, sweeping 3 games from Kansas City and taking 2 of 3 from Detroit.
The Sox are 11 games ahead of their actual 1957 pace:
Their lead over the Yankees has swelled to 13 1/2 games:
The Sox now return home for 3 games against the Kansas City A’s.
Chicago has added the following 7 players to the Roster for the month of September:
Earl Battey
Ron Jackson
Jim Landis
Barry Latman
Jim McDonald
Stover McIlwain
Don Rudolph -
The Sox took 2 of 3 from the A’s, and their magic number to clinch the pennant is now 5.
Game 1 of the series got off to a rough start for the Sox. Kansas City hung 6 runs on Jim Wilson in the first 2 innings, and Alex Kellner scattered 6 hits over 9 innings, shutting out Chicago. Lou Skizas was the star of the game for the A’s. He went 3 for 5 with 3 homers, driving in 5 runs.
Chicago bounced back in game 2, knocking Arnie Portocarrero out of the game after just 2 innings, scoring 3 runs off him. Minnie Minoso went 3 for 4 with 3 runs scored for the Sox. Billy Martin went 2 for 4 with 2 RBI in the loss for Kansas City.
Game 3 was the most competitive game of the series, with Jack Urban and Dick Donovan tossing zeros for the first 6 innings of the game. But the Sox broke through against Urban for 3 runs in the 7th inning. The A’s scored a run in the 9th against Donovan, but Gerry Staley relieved, and retired the final 2 batters of the game for the save.
The Sox now head out on their final road-trip of the season, a six-city, 14-game trip that will start out in Boston.
-
September 12 Update. Chicago takes 2 of 3 from Boston. Magic number is 2. Can clinch a tie for the division tomorrow against the Yankees.
Game 1: White Sox 10 Red Sox 3. Chicago jumps on Frank Sullivan early and often. He exits after 2 1/3, giving up 8 runs, 6 of them earned. Dixie Howell throws 4 innings in relief of Jim Wilson to earn the save. Minnie Minoso goes 2 for 4 with 4 RBI. Jim Piersall and Jackie Jensen homer in the loss for Boston.
Game 2: White Sox 2 Red Sox 1. Bill Fischer and Willard Nixon each go the distance. Luis Aparicio goes 3 for 5 with an RBI to lead Chicago. Billy Klaus drove in the lone run for Boston.
Game 3: Red Sox 7 White Sox 4. Bob Keegan exits early for Chicago, giving up 4 runs in 2 innings. Gerry Staley throws 4 innings of relief, but takes the loss giving up 3 runs. Ron Jackson goes 2 for 4 with 3 RBI for the White Sox. Mickey Vernon drives in 4 runs for Boston.
The season series between Boston and Chicago is now complete. The White Sox dominated the battle of the Sox, winning 18 out of 22 games. Chicago Outscored Boston by a 123 -65 margin. In 1957, the White Sox won 14 out of 22 games, and outscored Boston 93-72.
-
September 13. Game 139.
The Sox are unable to clinch a share of the Division title on this day, as the Yankees prevail 3-2. The Yankees built an early 3-0 lead off Billy Pierce, with RBI singles from Hank Bauer, Gil McDougald, and Mickey Mantle. Whitey Ford went the distance for the Bombers, giving up 6 hits and striking out 7 batters. Both Chicago runs came in the 8th inning on a homer by Walt Dropo.
The Sox will try again tomorrow to clinch a share of the division. They will send Dick Donovan to the mound. The Yanks will counter with Tom Sturdivant.
-
September 14. Game 140.
(Okay…I’ve got to check my math a little closer next time.) With their 4-1 victory in game 140 over the Yankees, the White Sox have clinched the American League Pennant (not just a share of it)
Dick Donovan went the distance for the Sox, giving up just 4 hits. The Yankees run came on an RBI triple by Elston Howard.
The White Sox runs came on a 2-run double by Sherm Lollar, an RBI single by Jim Landis. Jim Rivera provided the 4th run on a solo homer.
The season series between the White Sox and the Yankees is now complete, and it was dominated by Chicago. The Sox won 16 of the 22 meetings between the two teams, and outscored the Yankees by a 98-57 margin.
In 1957, it was the Yankees that dominated, winning 14 games against 8 losses. The Yankees outscored the Sox 99-83 in 1957. The 8 game swing matches the margin by which the Yankees won the division in 1957.
The Sox will now have 14 games to get tuned up for the World Series. They head to Washington to take on the Senators.
-
Thanks for the note Quinn. I certainly didn’t expect the Sox to do as well as they did in this replay. I’ve been able to stay really close to actual pitching usage…so It’s not because I’ve overused the top arms for the Sox. The Yankees really under-performed in the head-to-head match-ups with Chicago.
Did the Yanks win the division in your BBW Replay? By how much?
-
September 19 Update. Four more games in the book after the Sox clinched the Pennant. They split a pair of games with both the Senators and the Orioles.
Match-ups between the Sox and both the Senators and Orioles are in the books now.
Chicago took 16 of the 22 games against Washington in the replay. They outscored the Senators 136-59. Roy Sievers was the top batter for the Senators against Chicago. He hit .302 in 86 at bats, collecting 5 doubles, 1, triple, and 7 homers.
In 1957, the Sox actually did better against the Senators than they did in the replay. They went 17-5 against Washington in 1957, outscoring them 141-85.
The Sox went 13-9 against Baltimore, outscoring the Orioles by a 106 - 77 margin. Bob Nieman was one of the top hitters for the O’s. He collected 16 hits including 2 triples and 2 homers, while driving in 8 runs.
In 1957, the Sox took 12 games against 10 losses versus Baltimore. The Sox outscored the Orioles by a 77-57 margin.
Next up for the White Sox is 3 games in Cleveland against the Tribe.
-
September 22 Update. The Sox take 2 of 3 from Cleveland
Game 1: White Sox 7 Indians 4. Minnie Minoso hits a 3-run homer (10) and Ron Jackson drives in a pair of runs for the Sox. Dick Donovan (20-5) goes 8 innings to join the 20-win club, and Gerry Staley works the 9th for the save, his 19th of the year. Vic Wertz and Rocky Colavito each hit 2-run homers for Cleveland.
Game 2: White Sox 3 Indians 0. Barry Latman (1-0) goes the distance and shuts out Cleveland on 4 hits. Ron Jackson goes 3 for 4 with a homer (1) to lead the way for Chicago. Dick Brown goes 2 for 4 with a double in the loss.
Game 3: Indians 7 White Sox 5. Dixie Howell takes the loss, giving up 6 runs in relief of Billy Pierce. Rocky Colavito goes 2 for 4 with 3 RBI to lead the way for Cleveland. Ron Jackson drives in 3 runs for the Sox.
The White Sox finish up the road portion of their schedule with a pair of games in Kansas City against the Athletics.
-
September 24th Update. Sox split a pair of games with the Athletics.
In game 1, Alex Kellner shut the Sox out on 5 hits as the A’s won 5-0. Sherm Lollar had Chicago’s only extra base hit, a double. Bob Keegan (9-4) took the loss, giving up 3 runs on 7 hits in 4 innings of work. Woodie Held and Bob Martyn each drove in a pair of runs for Kansas City in the win.
In the second game, Bill Fischer (9-5) took a 1-hit shutout into the 9th inning, but lost the shutout with 2 outs, with the Sox holding on for a 4-1 win. Gus Zernial drove in the lone Kansas City run. Sammy Esposito went 3 for 5 with a double for Chicago.
The season series between Chicago and Kansas City is complete. The Sox took the season series 13 games to 9, outscoring the A’s 97 - 88. Gus Zernial was the top offensive performer for Kansas City in the series. He collected 23 hits in 85 at bats, include 7 doubles and 7 homers while driving in 19 runs.
In 1957, the White Sox took the season series from the A’s 14 games to 8. The Sox outscored Kansas City 101 to 72.
The White Sox now return home for the final 2 series of the season. First up is a pair of games against the Detroit Tigers. The Tigers are in 5th place in the AL, with a record of 74-75.
-
September 26 update. The Sox have crossed the 100-win threshold with a pair of wins over the Tigers, each by a score of 3-2.
In the first game, Jim Derrington exited after surrendering a run in 3 innings, but the Sox got solid pen work from four relievers, with Gerry Staley recording the last 2 outs for a save. Nellie Fox went 3 for 3 with 2 RBI to lead Chicago. Ray Boone homered in the loss for Detroit.
In the second game, Bill Fischer also left after 3 innings of work, but Don Rudolph followed with 6 innings of shutout relief to earn the win. Walt Dropo drove in a pair of runs for the Sox, and Earl Battey homered. Al Kaline accounted for both Detroit runs with a homer.
The Sox outscored the Tigers by a 79-68 margin in the replay, winning 14 of the 22 matchups. Frank Bolling was a top offensive performer for the Tigers, hitting .325 in 77 at-bats, with 5 doubles, a homer and 8 runs driven in.
In 1957, the Sox scored 105 runs against Detroit while surrendering 86 runs. The two teams split the 22 games in 1957.
The Sox close out the regular season with 3 games against the Cleveland Indians.
-
The White Sox wrap up the regular season by taking 2 of 3 from the Indians, ending the season with 103 Wins and 51 Losses. They won the Division by 13 games over the Yankees.
Finals Standings:
For Reference here are the actual standings from 1957:
-
Here is a pitcher by pitcher comparison of their replay stats versus actual 1957 stats:
Overall, I’m very satisfied with how the usage worked out with Jim Wilson being the only pitcher to significantly exceed his actual innings pitched.
While Gerry Staley (Az) did not exceed his actual innings, I did deploy him differently than he was used in 1957. In actuality, he was often deployed for multiple innings to replace an ineffective starter. I tended to use him as more of a traditional modern relief pitcher, deploying him in high leverage situations…but still using him for multiple innings many times.
It was the pitchers that fueled the Sox +13 game swing in the replay, as they prevented runs much better than the actual 1957 team did.
-
Batter by Batter comparison between replay and Actual Stats:
As usual, batting average comes out a little low, but extra base hit totals, walks, and stolen bases all came out right in line with 1957 actuals.
-
Impressive results, the most important indicator of the offense (runs) was just about on target. I played the the 57 season for awhile on BBW and the White Sox gave the Yanks all kinds of problems…